At NerdWallet, we try that can assist you make monetary choices with confidence. To do that, many or all the merchandise featured listed here are from our companions. Nevertheless, this doesn't affect our evaluations. Our opinions are our personal.
Airline reward packages have undergone dizzying adjustments lately. Incomes miles on many airways is now based mostly on how a lot you spend reasonably than how far you fly, and the variety of miles wanted to guide a given route has turn into more durable and more durable to find out.
To assist make sense of the confusion, we carried out a data-driven evaluation of main home airways to find out which supply the most effective bang on your buck – that’s, which program affords probably the most worth in return per greenback spent.
How we did it
To determine which program supplied the most effective return on spend, we would have liked to know:
- What number of miles you’ll be able to count on to earn per greenback spent (mile incomes fee).
- How a lot these miles are price (mile valuations).
Mile incomes fee
You continue to earn miles based mostly on distance flown on 4 main home airways: Alaska, Frontier, Hawaiian and Southwest. For these, we looked for the most affordable out there round-trip fares throughout 5 dates and 14 well-liked home routes, totaling 70 routes per airline. We averaged the value throughout the 5 dates and divided by the miles earned for every route.
4 different airways – American, Delta, JetBlue and United – challenge miles based mostly on the base fare, For these, we looked for the most affordable out there round-trip fares throughout 14 well-liked home routes and picked up each the bottom fare and complete fare. We divided the miles earned by the complete value of the ticket to find out the mile-earning fee.
Listed here are the outcomes:
In different phrases, when you spend $ 100 on a ticket with Frontier, you’ll be able to count on to earn 1,050 miles (100 x 10.5). In the event you spend $ 100 on United, you’ll be able to count on to earn 400 miles (100 x 4).
As you’ll be able to see, these incomes charges differ quite a bit. The highest incomes fee, Frontier, was greater than 4 occasions increased than the bottom, JetBlue.
In fact, these incomes charges elevate the query: How a lot are these miles truly price?
»Be taught extra: Journey loyalty program critiques
In a separate evaluation, we in contrast money costs and award redemptions for a similar round-trip routes throughout a number of locations and dates.
For instance, we in contrast the price of flying round-trip from New York to London utilizing both money or miles. We divided the price of the money ticket by the price of the reward ticket to find out a “cent per mile” worth for every flight, then averaged these values.
Listed here are the outcomes:
Drumroll, please …
Discovering the return on spend was then merely a matter of multiplying the mile incomes fee by the mile valuations and dividing by 100 to make it a share. Listed here are the outcomes, from the highest-earning program to the bottom:
Which means that when you spend $ 100 on an Alaska Airways flight, you’ll be able to count on to get $ 7.50 in worth from the miles you’ll earn. And you may count on to get solely $ 3.10 in return from a $ 100 JetBlue flight.
Unsurprisingly to many, many of the distance-based packages outperformed revenue-based ones. In truth, Alaska’s Mileage Plan affords greater than twice the return on spend in comparison with United, American and JetBlue.
The underside line
Airline frequent flyer packages are all about paying you again for being a loyal buyer. However, as we discovered on this evaluation, the packages differ broadly in how a lot bang you get on your buck.
The restricted mile-earning fee among the many three largest U.S. airways – American, Delta and United – considerably reduces the worth of their reward packages. This issue ended up being extra vital than the worth of the miles themselves in figuring out general worth.
Alaska’s Mileage Plan program stands effectively above the pack and affords a stable worth for West Coast flyers, whereas funds carriers Southwest and Frontier supply surprisingly profitable packages in their very own proper.
Methods to maximize your rewards
You need a journey bank card that prioritizes what's vital to you. Listed here are our picks for the most effective journey bank cards of 2020, together with these greatest for:
Planning a visit? Take a look at these articles for extra inspiration and recommendation:
Frontier Airways bank card now a ticket to elite standing
Methods to get top-tier elite standing by bank card spending
Discover the most effective journey bank card for you